Announcing the new McLean Center for Metabolic Psychiatry Learn more.
Practical Metabolic Strategies for Women as they Age
Listen
About the host
Medical Director
About the guest
Nurse Practitioner
Cynthia:
A lot of the strategies that have gotten high-performing women through their teens, 20s, and 30s really backfire in perimenopause. I always say it’s the great litmus test of our lives. Are you prioritizing yourself? Are you prioritizing enough lifestyle interventions? Do you have enough healthy boundaries?
Perimenopause is the most important inflection point, I think, in a woman’s lifetime, only secondary to pregnancy and puberty.
Bret:
Welcome to the Metabolic Mind Podcast. I’m your host, Dr. Bret Scher. Metabolic Mind is a non-profit initiative of Baszucki Group, where we’re providing information about the intersection of metabolic health and mental health and metabolic therapies, such as nutritional ketosis as therapies for mental illness.
Thank you for joining us. Although our podcast is for informational purposes only and we aren’t giving medical advice, we hope you will learn from our content and it will help facilitate discussions with your healthcare providers to see if you could benefit from exploring the connection between metabolic and mental health.
I think today’s episode’s going to be a fan favorite because we get a lot of questions about perimenopause and menopause, about symptoms, about metabolic consequences, about the role of ketosis in intermittent fasting. So today, I’m joined by an expert on all these topics, Cynthia Thurlow. Cynthia is a nurse practitioner, and she has her own practice where she focuses on perimenopause, menopausal symptoms, lifestyle interventions as well as medication interventions, which she’ll talk about, to help with the metabolic consequences and to help people get through this, what she calls, chaotic period of life, as healthily and easily as possible.
We talk a lot about protein and timing of food and carbs, type of carbs, timing of carbs, exercise, what kind of exercise, and so many other lifestyle interventions, including hormone replacement therapy, including GLP-1s, what role those play. So really a pretty comprehensive discussion about this time of life and what women can do to help improve it.
So I hope you enjoy this interview with Cynthia Thurlow. Many of the interventions we discuss can have potentially dangerous effects if done without proper supervision. Consult your healthcare provider before changing your lifestyle or medications. In addition, it’s important to note that people may respond differently to ketosis and there isn’t one recognized universal response.
Cynthia Thurlow, welcome to Metabolic Mind. It’s great to see you.
Cynthia:
Oh, so good to, so good to be here. Thanks, Bret.
Bret:
Yeah, I am very excited for this, as is our audience, because we get so many questions about perimenopause and menopause and metabolic health and ketosis and intermittent fasting and how all these interact with each other. Because it’s a big struggle if it hits you out of the blue, and you don’t know what’s going on. And all of a sudden, things are changing. So we get a lot of questions about that, and you are the expert. So I’m so excited to have you on to talk about this.
Cynthia:
Aw.
Bret:
But first, before we get into all that, as I like to start, I want to hear from you. What is something that medicine gets wrong that you really wish were different?
Cynthia:
Oh, gosh. The whole impetus for why I left traditional allopathic medicine 10 years ago is we get it really wrong about nutritional advice. And to a point that it is to the detriment of our patients because a lot of the common information that we give our patients is actually contributing to worsening metabolic health, than if we really got clear and granular about the things that we know are going to help stabilize their blood sugar and going to be most beneficial.
So even 10 years later, I would say, without question, nutrition. And I think nutrition is foundational to our health, and I know you also embrace this as well.
Bret:
Yeah, and it’s so interesting in the political spectrum right now, there has been a focus on increasing medical education in nutrition and requiring 40 hours, which is great. But I’m concerned, what’s the next step?
What are they teaching? Not just how much are they teaching, but what are they teaching is also so important. And I really hope that groups are able to come together to make it meaningful for nutrition education, that is going to impact people’s health and metabolic health and not just check the boxes.
Cynthia:
Yeah, because I think in many instances, the more information, high-quality information we can give our patients about the way to eat, how frequently to eat, prioritizing protein, eating the right types of healthy fats, the right carbohydrates timed around exercise, around our menstrual cycle, or really cutting back on carbohydrates depending on our metabolic health status. Those are the kind of levers that I think have far more impact than a lot of other things that we like to focus on in a traditional kind of medical role.
And I recall probably 15 years ago, a lot of my cardiology peers would say things like, “We have this NP, and she really likes to talk about food.” And they would pat me on the back in a very kind of patriarchal manner. And the irony is a few years ago, I ran into some of them and they said, “Oh my gosh. You were way ahead of the curve, and we actually gave you a hard time. And you were actually absolutely correct that we should be having those conversations started and initiated a whole lot earlier for our patients.”
Bret:
Gosh, isn’t that funny to think about?
They’d be like, “Yeah, I’m not going to talk about nutrition. Let’s give them to Cynthia. She’ll talk about nutrition.”
Cynthia:
Yeah, no. They literally would make appointments on my books in the office in clinic to talk to their patients about food. And it was like, it’s this low-lift intervention. “Oh, we’ll just humor her, and the patient by having them see her.”
But I think that is probably one of the more disappointing things that I say. We’ve come a long way in 10 years, without question. We’re definitely heading in the right direction. But I feel like it’s still maligned. We’re still jumping to medical therapy as opposed to taking the time to talk about lifestyle, like overall lifestyle changes.
Bret:
Yep. Well said. Well said. All right. And that will fit into a lot of what we’re talking about today. So you have, I believe it’s you’ve, called perimenopause a metabolic stress test, right? Are those your words? Why is that? Why is it a metabolic stress test? What happens?
Cynthia:
I think that there’s, well it’s the hormonal chaos of midlife. It’s really speaking to changes in skeletal muscle mass. So the degree of sarcopenia we experience in the 40 to 49-year range could be anywhere from 3 to 8%. So as we’re losing muscle mass, we’re also losing insulin sensitivity. It’s also a time where we become much more sensitive to carbohydrates, and I’m talking about quality and quantity.
It’s also a time as we’re seeing alterations in skeletal muscle mass, insulin sensitivity. We’re also seeing changes in estrogen. We know that estradiol, which is our most potent form of estrogen that our bodies make prior to menopause, is critically important for insulin sensitivity. And I think throughout perimenopause, they call it the hormonal chaos of perimenopause. But in some instances, some cycles, we could have our estrogen levels could be 20 to 30% higher than any other time in our lives. And then the next cycle might be completely different.
But those alterations are also impacting this metabolic health crisis. And I think that a lot of women are surprised to know that until we go into menopause, we are largely protected cardiovascular-wise from heart attacks. I say largely. It doesn’t mean they don’t happen. But I think in many instances, women are surprised to know that one in three women will die of heart disease.
And so this larger conversation about changes in insulin sensitivity, changes in dietary things, changes related to skeletal muscle mass are oftentimes surprising. And it’s also the time in a woman’s life where children are older, parents are aging, sandwich generation, greater demands from work. A lot of my patients aren’t sleeping as well.
We know sleep and insulin sensitivity are intricately interwoven. We know stress management becomes even more important. And I remind women all the time that if you’re dealing with chronic stress, cortisol is up. So is glucose. So is insulin. You’re going to be dealing with more metabolic health issues. And I just think a lot of people seamlessly go from their 20s to their 30s, and they stumble into their 40s,. And then all of a sudden, everything feels a bit harder.
And so when we talk about this kind of cardiac stress test, metabolic stress test, it’s this lack of awareness that insulin sensitivity piece is happening seemingly overnight. And a lot of the strategies that have gotten high-performing women through their teens, 20s, and 30s really backfire in perimenopause.
I always say it’s the great litmus test of our lives. Are you prioritizing yourself? Are you prioritizing enough lifestyle interventions? Do you have enough healthy boundaries? Because if you don’t, your body is probably going to be letting you know. It’s setting off a fire alarm in the house. And can you pay attention to it so that you can course-correct?
That’s the beautiful thing is anyone that’s listening, whether you are not yet in perimenopause, you’re in post-menopause, there’s a lot we can change. There’s a lot that we can do that I always want that to be the message. But I think midlife is when we start to examine things a little differently.
Everything’s a little harder. Doesn’t mean it’s impossible. But suddenly, we have to work a little harder at some of the things that we took for granted in our younger years. I’m sure when you were in your, when you were in your medical training, when I was in my training years ago, I could get away with three or four hours a night of sleep consistently for days on end.
Those days are over. And so a lot of my patients, it’s reframing all those lifestyle pieces that do play an enormous role in how we navigate midlife and beyond. Yeah.
Bret:
Now, when you talk about perimenopause, you’re talking about the hormonal chaos that it can be. Your estrogen can be high. It can be low. It can be in between.
It’s all over the place. Once you hit menopause, that sort of stops. That chaos stops. But do you think of the metabolic challenges and the metabolic consequences similarly for post-menopause as perimenopause?
Cynthia:
It’s interesting. I probably had a differing opinion on this 10 years ago than I do now.
I think that for a lot of women, menopause or post-menopause, and for argument’s sake, we’ll just say menopause to encompass 12 months without a menstrual cycle and the time afterwards, where women will spend a third of their lifetime. I think it is even more important in perimenopause for women to be aware of what’s coming because it is such an abrupt and jolting experience.
Rarely do I interact with patients or women online or podcast listeners that will not share with me that it was the hardest time in their lives, that seven to 10 years preceding menopause, because so much is changing. I think that perimenopause is that inflection point where women are really invited to make changes to lifestyle to allow themselves to reflect on what is working for them and what is not, and then course correct.
So I think perimenopause is critically important, and it’s also why these conversations are so important for younger people. I think that I certainly was not aware of what was coming. I don’t think anyone in my generation, in fact, the word perimenopause was never used in any of our textbooks or conversations in graduate school or in undergrad, which to me is astounding because my girlfriends and I talk about this all the time.
Does anyone still have an old textbook? Did we ever have a conversation about any of these midlife-related challenges? No. There was little to no education. So perimenopause is the most important inflection point, I think, in a woman’s lifetime only secondary to pregnancy and puberty.
Bret:
And it’s interesting because if a woman is going through perimenopause, and she goes to her doctor’s office and gets blood work and she has a normal CBC. Normal metabolic panel. Her fasting glucose is normal.
Maybe they even check an A1C, which is normal. I think it’s common for them to be told, “Look, you’re going through perimenopause. Everything looks fine. Give it time. It’s going to pass.” Like that type of advice, right? Am I? Is that common?
Cynthia:
Oh, absolutely.
Bret:
Yeah.
Cynthia:
Oh, you can’t test for perimenopause.
I hear that all the time. There are no labs that are going to help you navigate perimenopause. And I think that’s really an incredible disincentive for women because they hear that, and they’re like, “What I’m experiencing is real. And how do I seek validation for the constellation of symptoms I’m experiencing?”
I had a patient tell me the other day that her internist told her, “There’s no way you’re in perimenopause.” She’s 42. I said, “You are absolutely in the prime age range for perimenopause.” If the average age of menopause is 51, 10 years preceding that, I see women in their mid to late 30s who are perimenopausal.
So I think that there are clues, and I always say cyclical symptoms that people experience. If a woman is in early perimenopause, she may have more heightened symptoms around her menstrual cycle. So the week, seven to 10 days preceding, more anxiety, more depression, more insomnia, heavier menstrual cycles.
That is without question. It’s just the very beginning. It’s like the tip of the iceberg, but there’s so much more that’s ongoing. So when people say that there’s no official test for perimenopause, I’m like, “That’s not really true because there are things that will give you insights into where someone is on their ovarian trajectory.”
But I think that kind of the traditional model, and I don’t want to beat a dead horse, but I think the more traditional model, there is not per se like one test that tells you everything. It’s really an astute clinician looking at symptoms and patterns that they’re seeing and that the patient’s reporting.
Bret:
Yeah, and a lot of the tests that we use, if I’m approaching it from the metabolic side of things, a lot of the tests we use are from very downstream sort of late effects. So the early effects of abnormal insulin, HOMA-IR, or even body composition changes, those may not be tested. Or like you were saying for the insulin resistance test, may vary according to the time in the cycle.
So it is a little bit harder to capture. And if you’re not capturing it, you’re not prioritizing it. And yeah, I think that’s a big part of sort of the treatment that’s maybe missing that you talk a lot about. So what do you think some of the main treatment interventions need to be when someone is experiencing body composition changes, is going through perimenopause, and isn’t sure where to turn and what’s going on?
Cynthia:
Yeah. I go back to the foundations. I’m like if you’re not sleeping, we need to address that first. And so for some patients, that can be sleep hygiene, like as simple as you need a cold, dark room. You need to tell your partner he has to put an extra blanket on. You need to wear blue blockers in the evening.
It may be that you’re not eating two to three hours before bedtime. It may mean that you need to exercise because we know that people that exercise are actually going to have better sleep quality. And beyond that, it’s do you need L-theanine? Do you need some adaptogenic herbs, like ashwagandha, rhodiola, or Relora?
Or are you at the point now where I think you are in the stage of perimenopause where you would benefit from oral micronized progesterone, and that has a wonderful effect. There’s a downstream metabolite, called allopregnanolone, that has a nice sedating effect. And for the majority of my patients, that’s a starting point.
I would say stress management. We become less stress resilient. It is cruel that one of the few hormones that goes up in midlife is cortisol. And so I remind women all the time that a little bit of cortisol isn’t a bad thing. I’m sure if you measured our cortisols right now, I’m excited, I’m engaged to be having this conversation.
My cortisol might be up a little bit. But we’re talking about the chronic, unrelenting cortisol issues related to chronic stress. Meal frequency. So talking to my patients, are you eating five or six mini meals a day? Or when do you break your fast if you’re intermittent fasting? Or what is your first meal of the day?
What does your second meal of the day look like? We know that we’re more insulin sensitive during the day. So a lot of the conversation is around, I’d rather you break your fast at 9 or 10 AM than eat your last meal at 9 or 10 PM. Helping patients understand the need for adequate protein intake. How we need more protein with aging, not less. The right types of carbohydrates.
I’m not anti-carb. But for a lot of patients, they’ve been brought up with a lot of processed pasta, bread, rice. And I’m like, “Let’s get those non-starchy vegetables on board, high-quality fats.” And then the other side of that is just frankly conversations around exercise. My generation got the memo about skinny is in. And I talk to patients all the time about the need for strength training.
And the more muscle mass we build and maintain, the more insulin sensitivity we have. So when we’re dealing with body composition changes, one of the first things I’m going to talk about is let’s get a bioimpedance reading. Let’s get a sense of how much lean muscle tissue you have to fat-free mass.
And so that becomes very important to really assess because largely my generation and certainly older generations, they’re obsessed with the number on the scale. And I always say the scale is important to a point. But your weight can fluctuate based on what you’ve eaten, if you’re stressed, if you’ve been traveling.
Are you hydrated? Are you dehydrated? Where are you in your menstrual cycle? And so again, the bioimpedance scales and readings, I think become critically important. So it’s always sleep, stress, meal frequency, nutrition. And then, also, thinking thoughtfully about exercise and in particular strength training.
The other thing that’s a low, kind of a low risk thing that I talk to patients about, is if you have not been physically active, what I want you to do is walk for five or 10 minutes. Provided you’re not having any significant symptoms of anything that I’m more concerned about, five or 10 minutes after a meal helping with glucose excursion.
Those are relatively easy things for most patients to be doing. And I think that those foundational elements that I talk about, I say majoring the majors, are going to be very important for those midlife patients. Because what happens in most midlife women’s lives, irrespective of whether or not they have kids or they have aging parents, they have more work demands. They’re not as physically active.
They’re on the go. So they’re grabbing the frappuccino in their car. They’re eating standing up. They’re eating when they’re stressed. They don’t manage their stress. They don’t sleep enough, and that’s like the perfect storm for poor metabolic health for a lot of patients. So that’s a starting point. I would say the other thing that I always talk to patients about is, talking about hormone replacement therapy. Because if women are far enough into perimenopause, they may also need some estradiol, plus or minus testosterone, plus or minus talking about GLP-1s, which I’m a huge proponent of.
And the research certainly suggests that women on a concurrent GLP-1 and also HRT are going to have better body composition. So it’s always an informed conversation to get a sense for where they are. But some of my patients are like, “I’m miserable. I’ll take all the things. I’m willing to do all the lifestyle. And plus, please give me some HRT.”
And others are like, “I’m not ready, but what are the things that we can do in lieu of that?” And there’s certainly a lot that we can do.
Bret:
Do you sometimes come across patients, though, who want to take the quick fix? They want the drugs?
Cynthia:
Yes. Oh, absolutely.
Bret:
But they don’t want to do the lifestyle?
Cynthia:
Yes.
Bret:
And then is that, can that be counterproductive in some ways?
Cynthia:
Oh, I absolutely think it can be, especially when they’re plateauing. And they’ll say, “I’ve been on tirzepatide for a year, and now I haven’t lost any weight for six months.” And I would say, “Okay, I’m thinking about higher level things. But I’m also realizing when I said to them, ‘I need you to sleep more than six hours a night, and I need you to manage your stress.’ And I don’t care if that means you meditate or hum or stimulate your vagus nerve. Put your legs up a wall, go stare at the sunset, hug your pet, hug your loved ones so that your oxytocin will actually lower cortisol.”
A lot of the patients that see plateaus or are not happy with the end results, it’s because they haven’t done the concurrent lifestyle changes. And that’s why I always make the point of saying at some point you have to change your lifestyle. I know that’s not sexy. That’s oftentimes not what patients want to hear because it’s not the quick fix.
Do I think that there are people out there who can get by for a while with just taking the GLP-1 and not changing the way that they’re eating and not exercising? But it also comes at an expense. And I’m sure these are conversations you have with your patients, that if you’re taking a GLP-1, as just one example, and you’re not eating enough protein, and you’re not maintaining or building muscle, you are going to end up being less metabolically healthy overall because losing muscle mass is catastrophic.
And so I always talk to patients. I don’t care if it means you have a whey protein shake once a day. I don’t care if it means that you have to have essential aminos to kind of buffer your protein intake while you’re building this up. But the strength training is a non-negotiable. In fact, that’s part of a little client or patient agreement that I have with them just to reinforce the patients that are going to get the best results are the ones that are also concurrently changing lifestyle.
And I wish there was a magic pill. I truly do because I think a lot of people are very frustrated by the time they get to midlife. And I think a lot of women feel an inordinate amount of pressure to look a certain way, feel a certain way. And midlife can really be challenging mindset-wise.
Bret:
And so lifestyle has to be part of the conversation for us to have long-term success. And you’ve brought up exercise a couple of times, which I agree is just so crucial. Now, our producer, Erica, wanted me specifically to ask about weighted vests because she says when she goes outside to exercise, every woman over 40 is walking with a weighted vest.
So is that a, is that a easy way to get some increased resistance training with the added weight for your walking or has that maybe been over-hyped? What do you, how do you think about weighted vests?
Cynthia:
I think number one, they can be too heavy because I think a lot of women, the weights, the weighted vests are too heavy.
So you want about 10% of your body mass. And so for me, I weigh about 120 pounds. My weight, my weighted vest is 12 pounds. I will add it to a workout when I want to make it more challenging, meaning I don’t wear it on the treadmill and I don’t wear it walking. Because for me, personally, it can offset your center of gravity.
And so sometimes women, because of that additional weight on their shoulders, that can put additional strain on their joints, including their hips and even their knees. And so it’s always in the context of: are we looking to increase the intensity of workouts? And I have a home gym.
Sometimes I’ll put it on just to get my heart rate more elevated than it would be with just lifting weights. I think it’s always in the context of what is your goal. And for me, it’s just a more to add intensity to the exercise. It’s less about wearing it all over the place. I think I have some women in my neighborhood, I live in a very hilly part of my state.
There is not a flat place in my neighborhood. It’s all hills. And I see a lot of these women, they’re walking three or four miles in the morning with their weighted vests. And I’m like, “I think you have to be thinking long term.” Now, I did talk to an exercise physiologist, who actually felt that a weighted belt was a better weight distribution than a weighted vest.
So I think I would encourage people to try it out. Make sure you’re not using too much weight. My husband, the first time he got me a weighted vest, he got me 20 pounds, and I felt like I was melting. I was like, “Wow. That was, on my frame, was too much weight.” So now it actually weighs down a piece of furniture on our front porch.
But I think it’s make sure you’re not using too much weight and be thinking thoughtfully about why are you wearing it. If you’re wearing it because you think it’s trendy, that’s not the right reason to wear it. If you’re wearing it because you want to increase the intensity of your workout, I also don’t think weighted vests, per se, are going to impact bone mass.
A lot of people say, “Oh, I’m wearing it because I want to improve the quality of my bone.” And I’m like, “You’d be better off doing jump exercises or being very clear and intentional about strength training plus or minus HRT, plus or minus fiber.” Which we could even get into the research on fiber and the gut-bone access.
But I think for a lot of people, they do it because they think it’s going to help with their bones. And I’m like, “There’s actually other things you can do that I think can be more helpful.”
Bret:
Okay. Yeah, that’s a really good perspective. I want to also circle back to intermittent fasting, which is something you talk a lot about. And you already mentioned the earlier window better than the later window in terms of when we are most insulin sensitive.
But what about the duration? Everybody wants to know, what is the sweet spot? The maximum benefit for the least amount of struggle? So what is the sweet spot? But also, does your advice on intermittent fasting change for someone who has different cravings or symptoms during their cycle or someone who is now post-menopausal?
Does the intermittent fasting prescription change based on that?
Cynthia:
Yeah. I think everyone, it’s the million-dollar question, right? Everyone wants to know what’s the perfect ideal window for me. Very bio-individual. So number one, if a woman is still getting a menstrual cycle, under the age of 35, I’m super protective of women still in their peak fertile years.
I’m like there is a time In which fasting is reasonable and a time you should not be fasting. Because I think about a woman’s menstrual cycle as another vital sign, just like blood pressure or pulse. It’s really important. So young, thin women, not a fan of a lot of fasting. I think that there can be cycles in their follicular phase when estrogen predominates where they can get away with a bit more hormetic stress versus after ovulation before their menstrual cycle starts.
I don’t want them having a really restrictive pattern. They can do 12 or 13 hours of digestive rest. In fact, everyone listening, at a minimum can do 12 to 13 hours of not eating. Now the question becomes what’s best for midlife women? Again, very bio-individual. So if a woman is sleeping through the night and managing her stress, and she can get enough protein into her feeding window. And for me, that’s no less than 100 grams a day.
And for some people, they’re like, “Whoa, wait a minute. I get 40 or 50.” I’m like, “All right. That’s the first thing you need to work on because we need more protein intake in midlife than we did when we were younger to trigger muscle protein synthesis.” There’s a leucine threshold that we have to be thoughtful of.
So number one, is your fasting window allowing you to, your feeding window, excuse me, allowing you to consume at least 100 grams of protein a day? If the answer is no, your feeding window is too wide or too small, too narrow. The other thing is for midlife women, if they’re not sleeping, they’re not managing their stress. They can’t get enough protein in, then they probably have to be really conscientious and intentional because the stress of not sleeping enough and not managing your stress is going to undermine the amount of hormetic stress you’re getting from intermittent fasting.
And so I will sometimes say to women, “If you’re, again, in that follicular phase of your menstrual cycle where an estrogen predominates and you’re in perimenopause, you can probably get away with a little bit of fasting.” If you’re not metabolically healthy, you absolutely want to have a compressed feeding window because you probably would benefit from not eating for 15-plus hours a day.
I think the other side of that is in menopause, it’s very bio-individual. Some of my patients still continue to do well, and they can get enough protein in and they feel great. Other ones will find that they’ll have a stressful event, a death in the family, a divorce, someone lost their job, and intermittent fasting is too much stress.
It’s like adding gasoline to a fire, and they’ll start gaining weight. They’ll start finding out that they’ve whittled themselves down to 600 or 700 calories a day. And so we have to have these conversations about saying there’s a time and a place. I think intermittent fasting can be part of the conversation for men and women, but it’s always in the context of what other stressors are going on in your personal life.
I will share transparently, in 2024, my dad died. And it was like the start of everyone in their adult lives has years like this, where it was like literally multiple family deaths. My husband got sick, and I was writing a book. It was so much gasoline to the fire that I backed off on fasting because it was just too much stress for my body.
And I would encourage listeners to be cognizant of what are the signs that your body’s telling you this is working for you. You sleep through the night. You’re not waking up. You can manage your stress effectively. You’re not cold all the time while you’re fasting, which is a sign your blood sugar might be low.
Could be signs of other things, but that’s always a thing that I ask my patients to be really conscientious and aware of. The cravings thing sometimes women get cravings around their menstrual cycle. They may crave salty foods, sugary foods. They may crave magnesium-rich foods.
They may crave junk in general because they’re just not feeding themselves enough. So I would say cravings are a symptom. Cravings are oftentimes of a symptom of not nourishing our bodies. And this is in the context of someone’s eating a nutrient-dense whole foods diet, and there’s a sudden change. Or someone’s been fasting for a while and all of a sudden they have incredible cravings that they literally can’t stop thinking about food.
And I always remind people that our brains are conditioned for worst-case scenario. So when our amygdala overrides our prefrontal cortex, it’s a sign that something’s not right. And so it could be temporarily. It could be the amount of stress someone’s experienced. It could be that they’re just not nourishing their bodies.
And more often than not, when I’m looking at food diaries, when I’m asking women honestly, I’m like, “Don’t tell me what I want to hear. Tell me so I can be most helpful to you.” And I look at their food diary and I realize you are eating 700 calories a day. Your body thinks you’re starving. This is why you weight loss resistant.
This is why you can’t sleep. This is why you’ve plateaued. And this is why you’re mad. You’re mad at me. But yet part of my job is to be honest and say, “I think this is the time that we really need to back off on the intensity of the fasting.” And in fact, sometimes on social media, I get in a lot of trouble when I talk about OMAD, one meal a day, because in most instances I have patients that just aren’t eating enough.
So I look at cravings as a symptom that something is not properly balanced. And I know no one in medicine likes that word balanced, but there is something off that we need to investigate further.
Bret:
Okay, yeah. Very good. I think that’s a great perspective on fasting. It’s not good or bad. It’s not right or wrong. But it has a place and a time, and that may change over time.
So I think that’s, yeah, that’s really good. So now let’s transition to ketosis for a minute. And I guess there are two ways to approach this, one, someone who’s already in ketosis, on ketogenic therapy and goes into perimenopause and menopause, or someone who is wondering if ketosis can help with the symptoms.
So let’s start with that one for a second. in your experience, can a ketogenic diet, can therapeutic ketosis, can that help with symptoms of PMDD, or just symptoms of the metabolic consequences of perimenopause and menopause? What do you think about that?
Cynthia:
Yeah. I think ketosis can be incredibly powerful.
I think most people walking around are in a position where they are not very metabolically healthy. Their body can’t tap into fat stores for fuel. And so, they’re riding that blood sugar rollercoaster. They have more energy dips. They have more brain fog. They have more blood sugar instability that’s showing up as they’re waking up at night because they’re having this blood sugar crash, or they’re dealing with weight loss resistance.
So do I think that ketosis or intermittent fasting used as a strategy to help with ketosis can be very beneficial for these patients? Absolutely. The challenge is always helping people get from point A to point B. Because for a lot of people, the thought of not eating as frequently can be scary.
So there’s a lot of scarcity mindset around that and helping them use strategies that they can do to prolong the fast without breaking their fast. I’m a fan, honestly, for people who’ve been in ketosis for a long period of time, I like themselves to be bumped out of ketosis. I was really low carb for a long period of time.
I always like to use myself as the example because it gives me some street credibility. I’m like, “I’m always experimenting, but I was really low carb for a long time. I would say bordering on ketogenic. And I’ve actually found as I’ve been in menopause, I actually do better with a little bit more carbohydrate.”
Now, it’s not a lot, but especially around workouts, especially around strength training. I actually, I just had some potato before. I just had my lunch. It was a little bit late for me, but just had a naked burger, some salad, and had some potatoes that had been roasted a couple nights ago. And so I think that the ketosis piece, if someone’s chronically been there, bumping yourself out episodically, I think is important.
And that might be contrary to what a lot of experts in this field will talk about, but I just find that my patients do a whole lot better when they have an opportunity to have some potato, or maybe they have corn, or maybe that’s the day they decide to have some gluten-free pasta, or whatever it is that they feel like they want to use to round it. Or maybe they have some tropical fruit.
They’re doing something just to bump them out of ketosis, and they tend to be much more compliant with recommendations overall. And this has just been my clinical experience, that patients appreciate a little bit of flexibility. Now, do I have patients, and I’ll be totally transparent, that if they can’t moderate, they need to eliminate?
I sometimes will talk about that online. That I have some patients that’ll say, “Such and such is my kryptonite. I can’t even eat a bite of that.” And I’m like, “Okay. maybe we need to find an alternative that’s healthier for you so that you can still enjoy a birthday celebration and not feel like that then turns into a binge.”
So I think the ketosis conversation can be very helpful, especially for perimenopausal women who are starting to see their metabolic health decline. And sometimes they’re absolutely shocked. I think the ketosis conversation and bumping themselves out of ketosis is another side of that discussion that I think is important. And just the experimentation of the N-of-1.
So what might work well for 10 patients may not work for this five other that I have. And so being flexible for them allows them to feel like they have more control over a lot of things that make them feel like their body is out of control in midlife.
Bret:
Yeah. One of the things we talk about a lot is what are your reasons for being in ketosis, and any opportunity to reassess that.
Now, if you’re using it to treat a serious mental illness or an autoimmune condition or to actually treat a disorder, you’ll probably be less likely to want to come out of it. But if it’s for general metabolic health, for energy, you just think it’s the right way to eat and then something changes, like menopause or perimenopause, then sometimes it is worth that experiment to come out of it and see how you feel changes.
I think that’s good advice. Just because we’re doing something before doesn’t mean we have to keep doing it after as our bodies change like that.
Cynthia:
And I realize I didn’t answer your question about PMDD. I do want to answer that. I find that women that have the worst PMS symptoms, whether it’s severe PMS, severe PMDD, are also the women that tend to have a bumpier ride in perimenopause. And let me explain why.
There are some women that are just more sensitive to the alterations in hormones, the drop in progesterone that happens, the drops in estrogen, than other women. And that is the bio-individuality of that individual. Now, I’m certainly not a PMDD expert. But what I have seen clinically is that those women even more so need interventions a whole lot earlier.
They may need oral micronized progesterone. They may need to have a consult with psychiatry because they actually benefit from being on an SSRI or something to help them buffer the volatility of symptoms that they experience. And I think in many instances, I’m always open. I’ll say, “If you want to try ketosis to see if that would be helpful for your symptoms around your cycle, I’m completely open to that.”
But I also say to them, “It has been my clinical experience that women that have severe PMS, PMDD tend to have a bumpier ride through perimenopause because of the high and low lows of hormones.” And like I said earlier, Estradiol, which is tied into serotonin and dopamine. Progesterone is tied into GABA, our main inhibitory neurotransmitter.
So when those alterations are happening and women are experiencing mood changes, mood instability, irritability to a level where they feel like they can’t function, that is absolutely real.
Bret:
So you’ve mentioned hormones a number of times, and obviously, it’s important. Very important. But hormone replacement has gone through sort of evolutions and cycles, especially if you used to work in cardiology, right?
Cynthia:
Yep.
Bret:
First the observational study said it’s great for heart health. Everybody should do it. Then when trials said, “Oh, it increases blood clots. Nobody should do it.” And it’s now, nobody should ever get it. Not exactly, but that’s sort of the perception that was. And now. It’s coming back in favor more directed, more intelligently.
So how do you see it, though, in terms of hormone replacement therapy for someone who’s going through perimenopause or menopause and experiencing a lot of the metabolic consequences of that?
Cynthia:
Yeah. I am old enough to have been an NP at the time that the WHI, the Women’s Health Initiative, came out. So I was neatly tucked away in cardiology. Told me to stay in my lane. And I had a lot of patients that were very upset that they were taken off of their hormones.
So the whole Boomer generation really got the proverbial short end of the stick. I am grateful that the pendulum has started to swing a different direction. Because I do think that when we talk about estradiol therapy in particular, and if we talk about the changes that are happening at a cellular level as estrogen is declining, endothelial dysfunction, declines in nitric oxide production, increasing cardiovascular risks, I think HRT is a critically important conversation and really one to be started in perimenopause because we now know the benefits.
We talk about these windows. And for every person who screams about the window of opportunity, there’s someone else that says that’s not really true. We can still start it in menopause, and that’s true. But the longer a woman goes without estrogen, the more likelihood we are to see those inflammatory changes and oxidative stress changes and the endothelial changes to the lining of the blood vessels.
So from my perspective, the conversation is made in perimenopause. I’m like, “Listen, this is part of the conversation so that you understand what are the documented benefits that we know of right now and the ones that I think are evolving.” And so I think about estradiol, in particular, as this potent, important part of the conversation about metabolic health, maintaining insulin sensitivity.
And the irony is, in the beginning, there was all these conversations about oral estradiol therapy and concerns about clot risk because they get this big first pass effect in the liver. And I have some patients, that is the right choice for them. But more often than not, women are using transdermal, so skin-absorbed estradiol therapy, and there’s a lot of options.
And sadly, we’re in the midst of a patch crisis here in the United States. So women are now on gels and sprays and e-rings and all sorts of other options to maintain their needs. But I think that the conversation needs to start earlier. And anyone that treats midlife women, and this is something that I’ve started saying more openly because every single practitioner that sees patients, that sees females, is going to see a midlife woman.
And whether or not you’re the person that’s prescribing it, there’s probably a clinical indication to say, “I’m the dermatologist. And although I’m not your hormone doctor, I want you to know the benefits of collagen and elastin changes. The changes that happen to your skin because of estrogen loss. The changes that are happening because of progesterone.”
We have estrogen, estradiol, excuse me, estrogen, progesterone, and testosterone receptors diffusely on every cell of the body. And so I remind people there’s no specialty that sees midlife patients that doesn’t have an obligation to at least say, “Hey, probably worth having a conversation with your medical team about the appropriateness of this therapy.”
So I think if one in three women die of heart disease. And we know that metabolic health issues really accelerate in perimenopause. To me, it’s just part of the conversation that we need to have. Whether or not it’s the right decision for that patient right then is really up to them, but at least then they’ve had a fully informed conversation.
Bret:
Yeah. Very good. Yeah, and it is interesting how things happen so it can happen cyclically in medicine and how many people were taken off of their hormone replacement therapy by reflex rather than having a more thoughtful discussion about it, which is hopefully where we are now. That in realizing how individualized it is and the type of hormones and the route of the hormones and the age that you start and how long and the dose.
Like all these things factor into it, and if you’re treating symptoms and whatnot. Yeah, I think that was a good perspective. So if we were going to boil all this down and just say, okay, these are the top three signs you need to look for to see if you are having metabolic dysregulation from perimenopause, what would you say the top three signs are?
Cynthia:
I would say number one, you’re seeing body composition changes, and especially fat around your abdominal area. So really, the visceral fat component. Women will sometimes say, “I lost my waist.” And like I want to hear more about that. And I’m not talking about the stuff we can pinch. I’m talking about the deep visceral fat.
I would say, number two is sleep piece. Sleep is not a sexy topic. But I tell everyone, I’m like, “I’m not talking about one night out of the month you don’t sleep well or you’re stressed about something.” Consistent poor sleep has a lot of metabolic effects. We know that if you have less than six hours a night of sleep, you have a 30% change in your glucose variability.
You’re not going to make good food choices the next day. I would say probably the third thing would be something along the lines of the brain fog piece, which can be from a multiplicity of things. A lot of people like to blame it on the hormones. And I’m like, it could be. But it could also be, if we think about it from the perspective of what drives brain fog, more often than not is inflammation.
And at the basis of poor metabolic health is inflammation. Weight gain, poor sleep, and then the piece about brain fog. Because I think brain fog is an interesting. Anyone that’s a clinician knows there are certain chief complaints that you go, “Okay, this could be 100 things.”
And brain fog could be many things. But more often than not, when I have a woman really complaining about brain fog, I’m thinking about mitochondrial dysfunction. I’m thinking about inflammation. I’m thinking about gut health. I’m thinking about blood sugar instability. There’s a lot there that could be an early sign that there’s some degree of blood sugar dysregulation that we have to look more deeply at.
Bret:
Yeah. And then you’ve already covered a number of helpful interventions. But again, I’m going to make you pick the top three. So then, what would your top three interventions be that someone can do today to help get past, or to help resolve, all those issues?
Cynthia:
Yeah. go to bed 30 minutes earlier. Notice I didn’t say an hour. Thirty minutes.
Number two, walk after at least your largest meal of the day, 10 or 15 minutes. Huge benefits. My last might be, this sounds silly, but hydration. A lot of the fatigue, the brain fog, the issues I see are people that are not properly hydrated. And we start losing some of those thirst receptors as we’re losing estrogen, which it’s like now I walk around with all these weird factoids in my brain.
I would say the close four to that would be, eat more protein. Because if you’re satiated, you’re going to make better food choices. And don’t be afraid of fiber. Fiber is affectionately the new F word. I get yelled at a lot online about fiber. But I do think fiber is a very important part of the conversation.
Bret:
Yeah. And I meant to circle back to when you mentioned going for a 10 or 15-minute walk after a meal. That’s probably one of the lowest lifts for maximum benefit interventions, you know on that ratio, on that scale.
Cynthia:
Yeah.
Bret:
Because that same 10 or 15-minute walk in between meals is still good and important but doesn’t have the same impact as doing it after a meal.
So the timing is really important there, which of course, if someone’s then taking care of their family or cleaning up, or now is your time to finally relax, it’s the last thing on your mind to want to do. But yet, so important to do. Do you find people have a little resistance to that when you recommend it?
Cynthia:
They think it’s silly.
Bret:
Yeah.
Cynthia:
I generally hear, “Old people in my neighborhood do that.” And I was like, “Maybe they’re onto something?” And if they have a continuous glucose monitor, I’ll say to them, “I want you to tell me what your glucose is before you walk and after.” And then, when they’re able to see that their glucose drops 20 points or 15 points or sometimes 30 points, they’re like, “Oh. Now I get it.”
Then, we talk about muscle and GLUT4 transporters, and how that’s a really great way to bring their blood glucose down. And so sometimes they have to see the empiric evidence where I’m like, “If you have a glucometer, check before and after.” I think for a lot of patients, it seems too easy.
Or I’m like, “Listen, you’re sitting in the airport waiting for your flight, and you just had a garbage fast food meal in the airport. Go for a walk.” Like most airports now you could walk for hours if you wanted to. But instead of sitting there on your iPad or on your phone, take a walk after you had your meal.
Bret:
Yeah. Now I can’t let the conversation go without letting you talk about fiber because, like you said, it surprises people and, we got to get some comments in the both positive and negative I’m sure, about fiber. So why is fiber more important? Like you say protein and I’m like, of course, that makes total sense.
Cynthia:
Yeah.
Bret:
You say fiber, and my eyebrows go up a little bit. So tell me more about fiber.
Cynthia:
I know. I know. I just wrote this book called, The Menopause Gut, which is really talking about what’s changing the gut microbiome in perimenopause and menopause. And one of the things I was surprised when I looked at the research is that when we eat fiber, some people know this, some people don’t. So for the benefit of those that don’t, I will explain.
We eat fiber, it goes through our digestive system. Gets to the large intestine or colon, gets fermented. And from the fiber, our body makes signaling molecules, called short-chain fatty acids. I think a lot of people have heard of butyrate. There’s acetate, propionate, et cetera. They do a lot of things. They help with mucus lining in the digestive system.
They help with endogenous GLP-1 regulation. They’re important anti-inflammatory signaling molecules. One of them even crosses the blood-brain barrier. The fiber becomes very important as women’s hormones are changing in midlife because, fun fact, fiber and the short-chain fatty acids that come from that can actually stabilize bone breakdown.
So osteoclastic activity can be stabilized not just by estrogen but also by fiber, and these short-chain fatty acids that come from that. So when I’m talking about fiber, I’m not talking about grandma’s Metamucil. I’m talking about if you have an apple, like a tart apple or a pear, or you’re having leafy green vegetables, you’re getting fiber.
And most Americans, standard American diet, is devoid of fiber. No surprise. It’s heavily processed. Now, I will say fiber is very bio-individual because what Bret might be able to eat or I might eat, might be different than listeners. And I acknowledge that. But when a patient tells me they do not tolerate fiber at all, the first thing I’m thinking of is what’s going on in the gut microbiome? Because as someone who spent 13 days in the hospital seven years ago after almost dying from a ruptured appendix, I went probably 18 to 24 months before I could tolerate fiber again. Because the antibiotics that saved my life, decimated my microbiome.
And the reason why I share this story is for a long time I could not tolerate fiber. It took time for me to, essentially, it’s like you’re rebuilding a muscle. I’m oversimplifying it. But the microbiome itself, you have to have the right constituents of not only bacteria. But the microbiome itself can be impacted by stress, antibiotics, toxins we’re exposed to.
So fiber becomes a part of the conversation largely, and I explain it to patients in a very easy, straightforward manner. I’m like, “Trust me when I tell you, your life will be better with a little bit of fiber in it.” Now, if you look at the standard guidelines, they want anywhere from 20 to 25 grams for women, a little bit more for men.
I have a lot of patients that don’t get above 15. And so we’re just constantly iterating on improving those numbers with the understanding that there’s more to fiber than grandma’s Metamucil.
Bret:
And I think it’s always interesting when you talk about fiber, though, to put it in perspective of the high-carb diet versus the low-carb diet, no question.
Cynthia:
Correct.
Bret:
If you’re eating a high-carb diet, then more fiber is going to mean more whole foods and is going to be more beneficial. But what is a little bit of a Wild West and a little bit contrary thinking is that on a low-carb diet, does the fiber still have the same impact?
Now, interestingly, the way you’re talking about it as signal molecules and gut health, you would think it could. But a lot of people have variable experiences with it, with lower-carb diets.
Cynthia:
Absolutely, and what’s interesting is I’ve started working with more microbiome testing in my practice. And what’s interesting as I say this, again, I use myself as the example, I don’t tolerate inulin, which is a type of fiber.
I know this. Sure enough, what showed up on my microbiome test that I needed to add because the bacteria that feed off the inulin are devoid in my microbiome. And so one of the interventions is I’m taking teeny tiny doses of inulin. So I think for a lot of individuals, the more we understand about the microbiome, the more fascinated I am with the fact that for each one of us, we probably have a different input system.
And the generalities that a lot of people hear, “This is good; this is bad.” I’m like, “Listen, maybe someone listening tolerates 10 grams, and that’s the best they can do. Great. That’s better than none.” But I think in many instances we think about fiber solely in the context of that gelatinous, nasty drink that our grandmothers used to consume back in the ’80s and ’90s.
But I acknowledge that eating it from nutrient-dense whole foods is a great way to buffer that.
Bret:
I think this has been a really good discussion with a lot of good take-home points for people to understand about perimenopause and menopause and the metabolic consequences and what they can do about it.
So I want to give you the floor for any last comments. And of course, to wrap up where people can find you to learn more about all the amazing work you’re doing.
Cynthia:
Yeah. Thank you so much for having me. It’s been an honor. Easiest to find me probably on my website. So www.cynthiathurlow.com. I have two books.
One is Intermittent Fasting and Women. The other book is called, The Menopause Gut. I do talk a lot about metabolic health in there, for sure, despite the title. I’m pretty active across social media, probably most active on Instagram. And I do have a budding substack that has become my new passion project.
I enjoy writing. And now that my kids are safely tucked away in college, I have a lot more time to do that. But you can grab me there or Everyday Wellness, and Bret has been a guest on there in the past. And metabolic health on my podcast always does really well. I think men and women are generally very hungry to understand more and see what they can do to support their blood sugar and metabolic health over time. And not just thinking of it as, “I’m in middle age, and there’s nothing I can do.”
I always say, “There’s always something we can do.”
Bret:
Great. thank you, Cynthia. I really appreciate it.
Cynthia:
Thanks for having me.
Bret:
I was really excited to have Cynthia on because like I said in the beginning, we get a lot of questions from all of you about perimenopause and about menopause and about the metabolic consequences. And she clearly is an expert on this.
She spends a lot of her time and her energy researching and understanding and helping people get past this period as healthily as they can. So hopefully, that was helpful for you to understand a lot of the symptoms, to understand some of the interactions with physicians, and more importantly, what can be done about it.
And there’s a lot. No question. It’s not just one thing, right? There’s a whole list. But I liked her prioritizing it. And so you know kind of what the big rocks are, what to focus on first. And most importantly, that there are things you can do to help with the symptoms to help with the metabolic health.
So again, hopefully, that was helpful. And please leave us more questions. We’ll be happy to have her back or talk to other experts about this because I know there are still lots of questions out there. So thank you for joining us, and we’ll see you next time at Metabolic Mind. Thanks for listening to the Metabolic Mind Podcast.
If you found this episode helpful, please leave a rating and comment as we’d love to hear from you. And please click the subscribe button so you won’t miss any of our future episodes. And you can see full video episodes on our YouTube page at Metabolic Mind. Lastly, if you know someone who may benefit from this information, please share it as our goal is to spread this information to help as many people as possible.
Thanks again for listening, and we’ll see you here next time at the Metabolic Mind Podcast
Explore metabolic therapies with Steven who put his bipolar 2 disorder into remission. Discover tips for beginners & pros on diet, lifestyle & wellness.
Read more
Dr. Bret Scher walks beginners through the practical basics of starting a ketogenic diet, covering which foods to eat and avoid, sample meal ideas, and keto-friendly snacks. He explains why he prefers describing foods as "compatible" with ketosis rather than strictly "keto" or "not keto," and emphasizes that lifestyle factors like sleep and stress also play a role in achieving and maintaining ketosis.
Learn more
Living with PCOS can feel like a collection of unrelated problems. Irregular periods lead to one appointment. Acne and unwanted facial hair lead to another. Weight becomes its…
Learn more
Learn how to build a healthy ketogenic diet with the best fat sources, avoid common keto mistakes, and understand the role of supplements, alcohol, and carb cycling. This expert Q&A explains how whole foods support brain and metabolic health, why processed keto products can be harmful, and how to troubleshoot issues like anxiety on keto.
Learn more
Explore metabolic therapies with Steven who put his bipolar 2 disorder into remission. Discover tips for beginners & pros on diet, lifestyle & wellness.
Read more
Dr. Bret Scher walks beginners through the practical basics of starting a ketogenic diet, covering which foods to eat and avoid, sample meal ideas, and keto-friendly snacks. He explains why he prefers describing foods as "compatible" with ketosis rather than strictly "keto" or "not keto," and emphasizes that lifestyle factors like sleep and stress also play a role in achieving and maintaining ketosis.
Learn more
Living with PCOS can feel like a collection of unrelated problems. Irregular periods lead to one appointment. Acne and unwanted facial hair lead to another. Weight becomes its…
Learn more
Learn how to build a healthy ketogenic diet with the best fat sources, avoid common keto mistakes, and understand the role of supplements, alcohol, and carb cycling. This expert Q&A explains how whole foods support brain and metabolic health, why processed keto products can be harmful, and how to troubleshoot issues like anxiety on keto.
Learn more
Sign up to receive science, strategies and stories of healing delivered straight to your inbox